Why "the dog did it" defense won't fly- and shouldn't

Injury Attorney Explains Why Driver is Responsible for Crash

Listen to Scott's radio show, "Cannon's Law- Opening Fire" on WYSL 1040AM and FM TALK 92.1, Saturday mornings 8:00-9:00, and Sunday evenings from 6:00-7:00.
The Dog Did It?
Having been blamed for destroying/eating/soiling uncountable sheets of homework since the time papyrus was first employed as paper, man’s best friend is now being blamed for causing a bad car accident in Livingston County recently.
According to an article in a Rochester newspaper, a man driving a pickup truck in the Town of Portage claimed he was caused to drift into the oncoming traffic lane by his dog, who was riding in the cab of the truck with him. The pickup truck slammed into a station wagon, causing the driver and his two passengers to be injured very badly. The driver of the station wagon and an adult friend were taken to Strong Hospital via Mercy Flight helicopters, while the driver’s nine year old son was taken to Strong with a severe brain injury.
Does the fact that “the dog did it” relieve the driver of the truck from legal responsibility for this crash? I sure hope not. Even if you buy his claim that Fido was acting up (and as an injury lawyer trying to shift the blame llike this really bothers me) , it is still the driver’s fault for not having the dog properly restrained in the first place to prevent him /her from interfering with the safe operation of the vehicle.
What do you think? Is it fair to make the dog a scapegoat ? Or am I barking up the wrong tree?
Bookmark and Share

Free Book

An Insider's Guide to Avoiding Mistakes That Can Ruin Your Injury Case

Read More

The Ultimate Guide to Protecting Your Family From Irresponsible Drivers in New York

Read More

Talk To Me

Please fill out the form and we will be in touch with you shortly.

Name:

Phone:

Email:

Tell us more:


Law Offices of Scott D. Cannon
28 Main Street
Geneseo, New York 14454
Phone: (585) 243-9330
Toll Free: (800) 343-6918

Get Directions